1. FinTalent
- Focus:
- Mortgage and finance broking only
- Model:
- Retained executive search
- Guarantee:
- 120 days
- Based:
- Melbourne, no Brisbane office
- Queensland:
- Brokers placed; more searches here than in Victoria (its own count)
- Average fill:
- 27 days
- Broking focus 10/10
- Principal fit 10/10
- Brisbane depth 7/10
- Evidence 7/10
Total34/40
FinTalent has no Brisbane office and doesn't pretend to. Its founder, Joe Shephard, runs its Queensland searches from Melbourne, and on his own count more of FinTalent's work is now in Queensland than in Victoria. Brisbane depth is 7 rather than higher because there's no office here and no named Queensland client on its site yet. It has a desk that only does mortgage and finance broking, and brokers placed in Queensland, some of them writing books that sit entirely in New South Wales.
The rest of its evidence travels. Strategic Portfolio Partners had a seat another agency held for five weeks and lost at offer. FinTalent had candidates in front of the panel twelve days after terms were signed and an accepted offer at day 42, after reworking the seat so it carried a trail share for a broker who stays.
The terms are retained search, a fee worked off base plus super and a 120-day guarantee. Joe runs every search himself and takes a handful of briefs at a time, so it's the wrong pick for a group hiring a dozen processors across south-east Queensland.
Joe Shephard's verdict: Queensland's broker turnover is 10.2% on MFAA figures, against 6.9% in Victoria. I don't read that as Queensland brokers being flighty. Retention tracks business model, support and culture far more than geography, so a high churn rate usually means more seats were filled on the wrong things. It's the argument in hiring for attitude over experience.