1. FinTalent
- Focus:
- Mortgage and finance broking only
- Model:
- Retained executive search
- Guarantee:
- 120 days
- Based:
- Melbourne, no Perth office
- Reach:
- Placed roles in every state
- Average fill:
- 27 days
- Broking focus 10/10
- Principal fit 10/10
- Perth depth 3/10
- Evidence 6/10
Total29/40
FinTalent ranks first for Perth on focus and fit, and the Perth depth score of 3 is there so nobody mistakes that for local presence. It has no Perth office and names no Western Australian client on its site. It publishes that it has placed roles in every state, and it runs a desk that does nothing but mortgage and finance broking from Melbourne, where Joe Shephard runs every search himself.
28Watt had spent five months trying to fill a seat itself; FinTalent rebuilt the brief and filled it thirteen days after the first email. Lagos Financial's first candidate was declined at interview, so the brief was rewritten instead of a second CV going out, and the right broker interviewed eight days later. In a small market a second run of the same ad starts with fewer people left to answer it, so the brief has to be right the first time.
It runs retained search, with a fee off base plus super and a 120-day guarantee. It takes a handful of briefs at a time and has nobody in Perth to sit in on your interviews.
Joe Shephard's verdict: The Perth broking story I'd point to isn't a recruitment one. When AFG invested in Perth's Lifespan Mortgage Services, the deal let the business restructure ownership as one founder neared retirement and appoint two director-level brokers with equity stakes, keeping the team intact. A Perth principal facing the same question needs a recruiter who understands equity, trail and succession, which is the subject of the people risk in buying a brokerage.